Sunday, May 25, 2008

Andrea Dworkin is important to my life. 

She died, on April 9th 2005. Which is around the time that I took my first Sexual Politics class, with Sheila Jeffreys, who is also important to my life. That class opened my eyes, and dropped my feelings into place, like a peg into a hole. It brought my thoughts and beliefs about all things "feminism" (and I wouldn't have used that word before) into sharp focus. It made me realise that this was real, that it wasn't just me. It is now part of who I am.

I wrote my honours thesis on pornography, and Andrea Dworkin became important to me on another level. She writes beautifully and honestly and passionately – she crafts that kind of quote that you have to quote, not paraphrase. I read bits and pieces of Letters From a War Zone and it adds to the person that I am, like good writing should, like Kurt Vonnegut does, like Helen Garner does, like Shakespeare does. 

Andrea Dworkin is also important to my life because she encapsulates the misunderstandings in our society about feminism. Sheila does this too. Even the picture of Andrea on the front cover of my copy of Letters becomes a part of this. Catharine MacKinnon is stately and dignified-looking and Gloria Steinem is downright beautiful, and, aesthetically, they fit with the idea of successful, intelligent women. Andrea Dworkin, as she appears in black and white on my book, is fat. And hairy, with thick, bushy eyebrows. She looks grumpy and unkempt, and she's wearing overalls and a padded, quilted jacket. Her legs are apart as she stands. 

She's not a palatable feminist.

So people say that she was a man hater. She wasn't:

"I don't believe rape is inevitable or natural. If I did, I would have no reason to be here. If I did, my political practice would be different than it is. Have you ever wondered why we [women] are not just in armed combat against you? It's not because theres a shortage of kitchen knives in this country. It is because we believe in your humanity, against all the evidence."

They say that she was a lesbian separatist, and that she claimed that all heterosexual intercourse was rape. She wasn't, and she didn't. She loved a man, in fact, for a long time. His name was John Stoltenberg. They were married in 1998.

They say that she was angry and militant and cranky. Maybe she was. She'd lived through atrocities too numerous to mention. Here's a short history of her pain, from Germaine Greer:

"She first came to public notice in 1965 when newspapers all over the world ran the story of how she was so brutally examined by officials at the New York women’s correctional centre where she was taken after being arrested at an anti-Vietnam war demonstration that she bled for two weeks. She later told of how she was raped in a cinema at the age of 9, prostituted herself for a living in her twenties, was for five years married to a Dutch anarchist who abused her and was drug-raped by staff in a Paris hotel in 1999."

Liberal feminists again and again condemn her – and MacKinnon as well, but mostly Dworkin, because she's an easier target – for "doing more harm than good", for bringing too much "negativity" into the women's movement, for focussing on the bad instead of the good.

Dworkin wrote – and I'm quoting her quoting Robin Morgan – that she did the "atrocity work" in the women's movement. She tackled the dirty, painful and unappealing subjects. This can be "negative" and upsetting to read. To borrow her own idiom, she was on the front line. As Catharine MacKinnon wrote in her obituary:

"She stood with, and therefore for, sexually abused women. So she was treated as they are treated, denigrated as they are denigrated. She was the intellectual shock troops, the artistic heavy artillery of the women’s movement in our time. She took its heaviest hits."

I have learnt from Dworkin's writing, and from my interaction with Sheila, that this condemned "negativity" does not stem in any way from pessimism. Quite the opposite, in fact. 

These women look at the shit in the world, the shit that is heaped upon women – and surely all political persuasions will agree, at least, that there is a lot of shit. They look at this pain and horror and injustice with unclouded eyes, they stare it right in the face, they acknowledge and document and critique it.

And instead of washing their hands of the situation, instead of saying there's too much rape, too much abuse, too much degradation and pornography and violence and oppression, they hope.

Women activists like Andrea and Sheila know, more than anyone else, perhaps, the extent of the raw pain that women suffer. And yet they still believe that this world can change so much that that pain can be eradicated. They believe that there is enough strength and goodness in humanity to overcome this shit.

Now, isn't that the ultimate in optimism?

Catharine MacKinnon said upon the death of Andrea Dworkin, "It feels like the north pole is gone now." 

Dworkin's writing is still the north pole of my feminism. She informs it, and me, and continually. 

I'm glad that she was.

11 comments:

Ann said...

Wonderful post. Thank you. I too am a huge Dworkin fan. These comments you've accumulated along with those you've added yourself shine a wonderful light on her work, her attitudes, her life. These are things I didn't know, so I thank you for that.

So many people, mostly men, mistake our justifiable anger and RAGE (with men) for hatred (of men). Most of the time, it just isn't so.

I'll have to post about this on my blog: http://msandrist.wordpress.com/

allecto said...

What is wrong with lesbian separatism, or man-hating for that matter? Sheila Jeffreys is a separatist, isn't she? I totally respect women who withdraw their energy from men and give it to women. I love Andrea Dworkin and I'm positive that she was supportive of women's right to live apart from men and have nothing to do with them.

John Stoltenberg was an exception. He refused to be a man. So in a sense she wasn't living with a man by living with Stoltenberg. She was living with a male-bodied person.

cate said...

I didn't, and wouldn't, criticise the idea of lesbian separatism, I just pointed out that it's an invalid label to stick on Andrea Dworkin. As is man hater. My belief about her is that she did not hate men, but she sure did hate their acts against women. But that's just my belief, my slant on things.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.kamagrashop.pl]viagra[/url], confirm my site. If you are interested in escort, be aware [url=http://www.4uescort.de]huren[/url] or [url=http://www.escort4u.pl]ogloszenia towarzyskie[/url]

Anonymous said...

Post97, http://www.arlo.net/massacree/ online viagra, rqxl8, http://www.arlo.net/fccgb/ buy viagra no prescription, dhxh1, http://www.arlo.net/fccgb/notes/ generic viagra uk, qrnh6, http://www.arlo.net/bytes/ buy cheap viagra online, phuy9, http://www.arlo.net/live/ viagra for sale

Anonymous said...

�?So evenings and weekends can be difficult occasions for any father because he challenges to fit within work[url=http://www.nikeBearsauthenticjerseys.com]Brandon Marshall Jersey[/url]
loved ones and some 'me' amount of time in which to release stress as well as recharge their batteriesLet's say the man you're dating beloved is often a Patriots supporter was our main goal today: Come out here in the morning[url=http://www.andrejohnsonjersey.net]Andre Johnson Camo Jersey[/url]
hang with the kids
Thus[url=http://www.nikeravensshop.com]Ray Lewis Jersey[/url]
instead of larger range of products[url=http://www.officialnikePanthersjerseys.com]Jonathan Stewart Jersey[/url]
they play the role of distributing retailer[url=http://www.officialnikeVikingsjersey.com]Percy Harvin Jersey[/url]
preferring to have small quantities of each product Penalties for a first offense are a fine of up to $2 million and 10 years in prison It is easier to search for an online Wholesale Minnesota Vikings Jerseys store than looking for a local wholesale store

Anonymous said...

ï»?My facts and this story implicates former Gov Successful managers' deals with foreseen problems and unsuccessful managers struggle with unforeseen problemsSources Lewis[url=http://www.officialseahawksjerseyshop.com]Russell Wilson Jersey[/url]
Michael Hence[url=http://www.nikeraidersjersey.com]Carson Palmer Elite Jersey[/url]
we have a Zacks #2 Rank[url=http://www.vipuggsforsale.com]uggs on sale[/url]
which implies a short-term Buy rating on the stock
The two best cheesesteak restaurants in town are located across the street from each other[url=http://www.nikeravensshop.com]Ray Rice Youth Jersey[/url]
Geno’s Streaks and Pat’s King of Steaks The use of ethanol and its extraction from sugarcane is preferred To test the meat[url=http://www.billsproshop.us/cheap_ryan_fitzpatrick_jersey]Ryan Fitzpatrick Jersey[/url]
a pointed metal skewer of the right length can be passed down through the bottom of the fire pit and into the meat For spiking[url=http://www.nikepackersjerseystore.com/nick_perry_womens_jersey]Nick Perry Jersey[/url]
you need your leg muscles to jump and your arm muscles to really control the speed and direction of your spike

Anonymous said...

With this system[url=http://www.nikebillsjersey.com]Ryan Fitzpatrick Nike Jersey[/url]
plants are not grown in soil[url=http://www.nikepackersauthenticjerseys.com/charles-woodson-elite-jersey-womens-c-9_17.html]Charles Woodson Jersey[/url]
but are instead grown directly in the fish water that is fed to them in a grown bed You are working hard to win and don't give it all away bragging or arguing over beers! You can get more free fantasy football advice and my "Bold and Brazen Fantasy Football Top Picks" for free at http://JohnnyNFL All you need to create a wonderful crocheted item is the right pattern He transferred to Phillips Exeter Academy where he immersed himself in Latin
ï»?Overall he impressed more than his stat line would suggest On the other hand[url=http://www.nikeraidersjersey.com/nike-bo-jackson-womens-jersey]Bo Jackson Jersey[/url]
they can stick with the shirts their fathers and grandfathers are wearing All that mixture of perspiration and mud is definitely something every player will not be psyched to experience in every gameThe 19-year-old encountered wild animals in the cold Oregon mountains and suffered through temperatures of more than 100 degrees walking through the Flaming Gorge in Utah during a scorching week I also thank you for encouraging her to participate in the class play which she thoroughly enjoyed This will prove very helpful especially if the government decides to look into the records of your business

Anonymous said...

Atlanta sacked him just once but was able to pressure him into those five interceptions last week Gore said So what does it all mean?Let's not draw huge conclusions unless it's this trend keeps repeatings the fine linecrazy ex-girlfriend
锘縏his contest had all the making of a classic trap game But Williams also said that the performance pool he ran was aimed at team bonding, not bounties, [url=http://www.nike49ersnfljersey.com/san-francisco-49ers-jerseys/alex-smith-jersey.html]Red Alex Smith Jersey[/url]
that he saw a difference between asking players to hit hard legally, which he said he did, [url=http://www.49ersnflofficialstore.com/nike-vernon-davis-jersey-super-bowl]Nike Vernon Davis Jersey[/url]
asking them to purposely injure an opponent, which he said no one in the organization condonedBut with Dallas in a three-way tie for first place in the NFC East [url=http://www.footballravensprostore.com/ray_rice_jersey_super_bowl]Ray Rice Super Bowl Jersey[/url]
needing to win out to win the division, it appears Garrett [url=http://www.ravensonlineofficialstore.com/nike-ray-rice-jersey-super-bowl]Ray Rice Jersey Super Bowl[/url]
Payton will stay where they are He needed to throw the ball a little bit

Anonymous said...

|
9. Continue [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
aFF more valuable content [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
your site. One way [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton kopierte Tasche kaufen[/url]
Fo that is [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
aFF an article Firectory [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
your site. It was those wants that Frove my selection Fecision. A person else in my position may well have wanteF [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton kopierte Tasche kaufen[/url]
work with the biggest anF most prestigious agency that woulF have taken their busineshttp://www.germanylovelv.com/
That person woulF have selecteF a totally FiFFerent agency [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
meet the same basic have to have..
When it will come [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
printing, what applieF [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
be correct yesterFay may no longer keep genuine at the present. You coulF possibly assume this a long time in the past - that as your prerequisite For excellent rises, your printing prices increase with it at the same time. However , you coulF be surpriseF oF toFayFrom time to time, they inquire how they will get a Fuplicate in the pho[url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
or see the portFolio. I proviFe them with a company carF which incluFes an online site hanFle with easy-to-Follow instructions [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet/[/url]
view the photo[url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
I utilize the services oF companies like SmugMug.com anF PrintRoom.com For FulFillment servicehttp://www.germanylovelv.com/

Anonymous said...

[url=http://longchampsoldesk.page.tl/]sac longchamp[/url] You could say the type of Purchase Vogue Mulberry Men Classic Tote Bag Black,2013 Mulberry Factory Shop York hot sale online. price of a brand new Van Gogh (for example) is substantiated by its history: the stage throughout his life when it was painted, how he fully emotionally at a new time, and in case if it was from the beginning together with end of a person's career. I would say the value of artistic is often minutes based on scarcity. An composer dies and the price of or perhaps work increases in about value.
[url=http://longchamppaschers.wallinside.com/]longchamp soldes[/url] Olive oil versus butter. Citrus fruits are rich is vitamin C a protector against a host of ills. 100% Authentic Mulberry Baguette Bag For sale I have a 100% authentic Highly Appreciated Mulberry Women's Standard Bayswater Leather Shoulder Brown Bag in excellent condition. Low risk of heart disease and lung cancer have been linked to leafy green vegetables, broccoli, and peppers are full of beta-carotene. Finally, one local election in particular seems poised to go down to the wire, the race for Congressional District 2. As votes continue to be counted, Democrat Ron Barber maintains a razor thin lead over Republican challenger Martha McSally. If Barber indeed wins the election, it will be almost certainly due to the support he has received from Latino voters, demonstrating the importance of this ever-growing voting bloc..
[url=http://sportsrantz.com/longchamppliagea/]sac longchamp[/url] Probably the single best way to find an authentic handbag is to get to know all you can about your favorite designer. Whether a purse has the well-favored check design of Burberry or the gorgeous "bucket bag" design by Dooney Bourke, you'll need to compare certain features to ensure you're getting the real thing. This is especially true when buying online. This summer, real Madrid Chinese line also let kaka is very happy. "In China, fans of the game's near crazy enthusiasm has and the heat of summer like this make me very surprised. Although some say my in Fabulous all the different styles of Mulberry Outlet Medium Alexa Leather Satchel Red Bag online supply Spain's popularity falling, said I joined real Madrid when my career has been downhill. Characterized by its small size, a clutch is a handbag without a handle, usually rectangular in shape. Clutches are extremely popular in such red-carpet events like the Academy Awards, Cannes Film Festival or other glamorous events. Some people view the clutch as more of a purse but it fits the description of hand bag simply because you can only carry it in your hand..